Every slice tells a story worth savoring

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe started with a simple belief: that the best moments in life happen around a slice of something made with care. Nestled along Lake Erie in Ashtabula, we've been serving up handcrafted pies and comforting cafe fare since day one.

Every crust is rolled by hand. Every filling is made from scratch. We source locally whenever we can and let the seasons guide our menu — because pie should taste like the time of year it was made.

Whether you're joining us for a quick coffee and a slice, a leisurely lunch, or an order to take home, we want you to feel that same warmth we feel when we pull a fresh pie from the oven.